Journals
2024
An interpretable isoflux-based observer for plasma shape control errors in tokamaks
A Tenaglia, F Pesamosca, F Felici, D Carnevale, S Coda, A Mele, A MerleIn tokamaks, plasma shape control is often achieved through a so-called isoflux approach that regulates the poloidal flux differences between a reference point and a set of control points and magnetic field values at suitable locations to obtain the desired shape. Despite its simplicity, this approach presents two primary drawbacks: first, a method is needed to translate desired shape modifications, e.g., radial or vertical shifts, into variations of the poloidal flux and magnetic field references; second, interpreting controller performance metrics may not be straightforward, since control errors are expressed in terms of physical quantities, i.e., flux differences, magnetic fields, that cannot be directly related to positional errors. In this work, we propose a comprehensive methodology to establish relationships that link variations of poloidal flux and magnetic field values concerning a nominal plasma equilibrium in a predefined set of shape control points to local deformations of the Last Closed Flux Surface (LCFS). The effectiveness of this approach is demonstrated on the Tokamak à Configuration Variable (TCV) model through extensive simulations that consider various plasma configurations and shape modifications.
Automated shot-to-shot optimization of the plasma start-up scenario in the TCV tokamak
LE Di Grazia, F Felici, M Mattei, A Merle, P Molina, C Galperti, S Coda, B Duval, A Maier, A Mele, A Perek, A Pironti, T Ravensbergen, B Vincent, C Wüthrich and the TCV teamPlasma start-up is typically achieved manipulating poloidal magnetic fields, gas injection and possibly auxiliary heating. Model-based design techniques have been gaining increasing attention in view of future large tokamaks which have more stringent constraints and less room for trial-and-error. In this paper, we formulate the tokamak start-up scenario design problem as a constrained optimization problem and introduce a novel shot-to-shot correction algorithm, based on the Iterative Learning Control concept, to compensate for unavoidable modeling errors based on experimental data. The effectiveness of the approach is demonstrated in experiments on the TCV tokamak showing that the target ramp-up scenario could be obtained in a small number of shots with a rough electromagnetic model.
Development of SPARC plasma disruption database through electromagnetic predictive MAXFEA Modelling
M Scarpari, R Lombroni, A Mele, S Carusotti, S Minucci, G Liuzzo, M Notazio, V Riccardo, G Calabrò, P FanelliThe evaluation of electromagnetic (EM) behaviour of tokamak components under disruption loads and its correlation with vertical instabilities is critical and characterizing the design considerations. This is particularly crucial for high-field and burning plasma experiments such as the SPARC tokamak, the compact prototype currently under construction by Commonwealth Fusion Systems (CFS). The combination of high toroidal magnetic field (12.2 T) and high plasma current (8.7 MA) makes SPARC less tolerant to disruptions than currently operating research devices. In this context, recent efforts have been made to characterize the disruption loads in SPARC by conducting a series of analyses to estimate the EM response of the SPARC vacuum vessel (VV) during a plasma vertical displacement event (VDE). In this paper, the aforementioned analyses are used as starting point for a comprehensive characterization of VDE scenarios. These analyses are utilized to create a database of predictive disruption simulations, serving as synthetic experiments to generate and collect pertinent data for upcoming research studies. In this context, the paper discusses a preliminary description of an innovative VV synthetic displacements diagnostic, designed starting from disruption database, presented here, and by exploiting the MAXFEA-ANSYS combined use methodology as further step. The disruptive plasma scenarios database will be functional in estimating the displacement and strain fields of SPARC components using a limited set of VV indirect displacement measurements and integral plasma observations, such as plasma current and effective plasma position.
A data-driven Vertical Stabilization system for the ITER tokamak based on Dynamic Mode Decomposition
LE Di Grazia, M Mattei, A Mele, A PirontiIn this article, we propose an online method to estimate an approximate linear model of a vertically unstable tokamak plasma to consequently adapt the parameters of a Vertical Stabilization controller. The identification procedure is based on the Dynamic Mode Decomposition with control approach, while the tuning procedure takes advantage of linear control theory to impose the desired crossing frequency and gain margins. The proposed technique is aimed at controlling ITER elongated plasmas using the VS3 stabilization coils, located inside the vessel. The effectiveness of the method is proven by means of numerical simulations carried out with the CREATE-NL+ free boundary evolutionary code, also considering the presence of realistic measurement noise levels.
2023
Assessing the Finite-Time Stability of Nonlinear Systems by means of Physics-Informed Neural Networks
A Mele, A PirontiIn this paper, the problem of assessing the Finite-Time Stability (FTS) property for general nonlinear systems is considered. First, some necessary and sufficient conditions that guarantee the FTS of general nonlinear systems are provided; such conditions are expressed in terms of the existence of a suitable Lyapunov-like function. Connections of the main theoretical result of given in this article with the typical conditions based on Linear Matrix Inequalities (LMI) that are used for Linear Time-Varying (LTV) systems are discussed. An extension to the case of discrete time systems is also provided. Then, we propose a method to verify the obtained conditions for a very broad class of nonlinear systems. The proposed technique leverages the capability of neural networks to serve as universal function approximators to obtain the Lyapunov-like function. The network training data are generated by enforcing the conditions defining such function in a (large) set of collocation points, as in the case of Physics-Informed Neural Networks. To illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach, some numerical examples are proposed and discussed. The technique proposed in this paper allows to obtain the required Lyapunov-like function in closed form. This has the twofold advantage of a) providing a practical way to verify the considered FTS property for a very general class of systems, with an unprecedented flexibility in the FTS context, and b) paving the way to control applications based on Lyapunov methods in the framework of Finite-Time Stability and Control.
Implementation of a high-speed multichannel data acquisition system for magnetic diagnostics and plasma centroid position control in ISTTOK
D Corona, A Mele, N Cruz, H Alves, B B Carvalho, H Figueiredo, H FernandesIn tokamak and other fusion devices, magnetic control is the main tool that allows to regulate the plasma current, position and shape; it is in charge of actuating the desired plasma current waveform, steering the plasma position to a given set point and maintain the plasma shape close to a prescribed plasma equilibrium. This work describes the application of several physics concepts and computational tools in order to obtain a novel optimal controller for the plasma centroid position, which has been implemented and tested in the real-time plasma control system at the ISTTOK tokamak. A key point for the development of the new control system was the installation of a recently upgraded hardware, that numerically integrates in real-time the magnetic probes signals.
A Deep Reinforcement Learning approach for Vertical Stabilization of tokamak plasmas
S Dubbioso, G De Tommasi, A Mele, G Tartaglione, M Ariola, A PirontiReinforcement Learning has emerged as a promising approach to implement efficient data-driven controllers for a variety of applications. In this paper, a Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient (DDPG) algorithm is used to train a Vertical Stabilization agent, to be considered as a possible alternative to the model-based solutions usually adopted in existing machines. The agent is trained and validated considering the ITER tokamak magnetic control as case study environment. The tuning of the DDPG algorithm's hyper-parameters is motivated through a sensitivity analysis.
2022
Vertical stabilization of tokamak plasmas via extremum seeking
G De Tommasi, LE di Grazia, S Dubbioso, M Mattei, A Mele, A PirontiIn this paper we propose a vertical stabilization (VS) control system for tokamak plasmas based on the extremum seeking (ES) algorithm. The gist of the proposed strategy is to inject an oscillating term in the control action and exploit a modified ES algorithm in order to bring to zero the average motion of the plasma along the unstable mode. In this way, the stabilization of the unstable vertical dynamic of the plasma is achieved. The approach is validated by means of both linear and nonlinear simulations of the overall ITER tokamak magnetic control system, with the aim of demonstrating robust operation throughout the flat-top phase of a discharge and the capability of reacting to a variety of disturbances.
Implementation of a Kalman filter-based eddy current estimator for the P-EFIT magnetic equilibrium reconstruction code
Y Huang, A Mele, ZP Luo, M Mattei, A Pironti, BJ Xiao, QP YuanThis article discusses the integration of a Kalman filter in the P-EFIT equilibrium reconstruction code, with the aim of estimating the currents induced in the passive structures of a tokamak. The filter is based on a vacuum electromagnetic model of the reactor, and takes advantage of an estimate of the effect of the plasma on the magnetics, provided by the equilibrium reconstruction algorithm. On the other hand, the observer is integrated into the equilibrium reconstruction, which exploits the eddy currents estimates provided by the Kalman filter to refine the obtained solution. To analyze the interplay of the reconstruction code and the proposed observer, the ITER tokamak is considered as a case-study, and the algorithm is tested on a variety of plasma conditions, selected in such a way to maximize the relevance of an accurate knowledge of the passive currents. The code performance is evaluated in terms of convergence metrics, eddy currents estimation accuracy and reconstruction of plasma-related quantities such as plasma-wall gaps, plasma current and plasma profile parameters.
Plasma physics and control studies planned in JT-60SA for ITER and DEMO operations and risk mitigation
M Yoshida, G Giruzzi et al.A large superconducting machine, JT-60SA has been constructed to provide major contributions to the ITER program and DEMO design. For the success of the ITER project and fusion reactor, understanding and development of plasma controllability in ITER and DEMO relevant higher beta regimes are essential. JT-60SA has focused the program on the plasma controllability for scenario development and risk mitigation in ITER as well as on investigating DEMO relevant regimes. This paper summarizes the high research priorities and strategy for the JT-60SA project. Recent works on simulation studies to prepare the plasma physics and control experiments are presented, such as plasma breakdown and equilibrium controls, hybrid and steady-state scenario development, and risk mitigation techniques. Contributions of JT-60SA to ITER and DEMO have been clarified through those studies.
A deep deterministic policy gradient learning approach to missile autopilot design
A Candeli, G De Tommasi, D Giuseppe Lui, A Mele, S Santini, G TartaglioneIn this paper a Deep Reinforcement Learning algorithm, known as Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient (DDPG), is applied to the problem of designing a missile lateral acceleration control system. To this aim, the autopilot control problem is recast in the Reinforcement Learning framework, where the environment consists of a 2-Degrees-of-Freedom nonlinear model of the missile's longitudinal dynamics, while the agent training procedure is carried out on a linearized version of the model. In particular, we show how to account not only for the stabilization of the longitudinal dynamic, but also for the main performance indexes (settling-time, undershoot, steady-state error, etc.) in the DDPG reward function. The effectiveness of the proposed DDPG-based missile autopilot is assessed through extensive numerical simulations, carried out on both the linearized and the fully nonlinear dynamics by considering different flight conditions and uncertainty in the aerodynamic coefficients, and its performance is compared against two model-based control strategies in order to check the capability of the proposed data-driven approach to achieve prescribed closed-loop response in a completely model-free fashion.
2021
Finite-time stabilization of linear systems with unknown control direction via extremum seeking
A Mele, G De Tommasi, A PirontiIn this article, the finite-time stabilization problem is solved for a linear time-varying system with unknown control direction by exploiting a modified version of the classical extremum-seeking algorithm. We propose to use a suitable oscillatory input to modify the system dynamics, at least in an average sense, so as to satisfy a differential linear matrix inequality condition, which in turn guarantees that the system's state remains inside a prescribed time-varying hyperellipsoid in the state space. The finite-time stability (FTS) of the averaged dynamics implies the FTS of the original system, as the distance between the original and the averaged dynamics can be made arbitrarily small by choosing a sufficiently high value of the dithering frequency used by the extremum-seeking algorithm. The main advantage of the proposed approach resides in its capability of dealing with systems with unknown control direction, and/or with a control direction that changes over time. Being FTS a quantitative approach, this article also gives an estimate of the necessary minimum dithering/mixing frequency provided, and the effectiveness of the proposed finite-time stabilization approach is analyzed by means of numerical examples.
Preliminary evaluation of the LIUQE code reconstruction performance for the DTT device
A Mele, R Ambrosino, F Carpanese, A Castaldo, F Felici, A Merle, JM Moret, A PirontiThe Divertor Tokamak Test (DTT) facility is a medium-size tokamak whose construction is starting in the ENEA Site, Frascati. Its principal aim is to investigate alternative solutions for the power exhaust in view of future fusion reactors such as ITER and DEMO, and in this view a palette of several possible magnetic configurations is currently at study for this machine. As in all fusion devices, DTT will be equipped since day-0 with a suitable set of magnetic diagnostics, which is currently in the design phase. In this work, we use the FEM models of several magnetic configurations obtained with the CREATE-L/NL codes and a preliminary set of magnetic sensors to evaluate the accuracy achievable by the LIUQE equilibrium reconstruction code over a variety of magnetic configurations.
2020
On the numerical solution of DLMIs
M Ariola, G De Tommasi, A Mele, G TartaglioneThis paper presents a novel approach for the numerical solution of differential linear matrix inequalities. The solutions are searched in the class of piecewise-quadratic functions with symmetric matrix coefficients to be determined. To limit the numbers of unknowns, congruence constraints are considered to guarantee continuity of the solution and of its derivative. In Example section, some control problems involving differential linear matrix inequalities are considered and solved in order to compare the proposed approach with alternative approximation methods adopted in the literature.
GPU-optimized fast plasma equilibrium reconstruction in fine grids for real-time control and data analysis
Huang, ZP Luo, BJ Xiao, LL Lao, A Mele, A Pironti, M Mattei, G Ambrosino, QP Yuan, YH Wang, NN BaoP-EFIT, a GPU parallel equilibrium reconstruction code, is based on the EFIT framework, but built with the CUDA (Compute Unified Device Architecture) to take advantage of massively parallel Graphical Processing Unit (GPU) cores to significantly accelerate the computation. With the parallelized Grad-Shafranov solver and middle-scale matrix calculation modules, P-EFIT can accurately reproduce the EFIT reconstruction algorithms at a fraction of the EFIT computational time. Integrated into EAST plasma control system, P-EFIT not only provides control signal results but also enhance EAST plasma control capacity with unique designed function modules. Using the synthetic magnetic diagnostic signals from ITER plasma equilibria obtained by the CREATE-L and CREATE-NL codes in standalone and streaming mode, P-EFIT has good enough accuracy and time latency performance in most of the considered cases. P-EFIT achieves full kinetic equilibrium reconstruction algorithms and repeats the EFIT results with the DIII-D internal plasma current and kinetic profile measurements in one-percent cost time of EFIT. All these works suggest that P-EFIT can provide quality magnetic equilibrium reconstruction in real-time, offer full kinetic equilibrium reconstruction with high spatial resolution and high
A reduced basis approach to plasma equilibrium reconstruction in tokamaks
A Mele, G De Tommasi, M Mattei, A PirontiIn this paper, the Proper Orthogonal Decomposition approach is exploited to obtain a Reduced Order Model for the plasma magnetic equilibrium problem, described by the Grad-Shafranov equation. The proposed method is applied over a dataset consisting of a few hundred ITER plasma equilibria, and is applied to the problem of plasma equilibrium reconstruction.
2019
Advances in the physics studies for the JT-60SA tokamak exploitation and research plan
G Giruzzi, M Yoshida, et al.JT-60SA, the largest tokamak that will operate before ITER, has been designed and built jointly by Japan and Europe, and is due to start operation in 2020. Its main missions are to support ITER exploitation and to contribute to the demonstration fusion reactor machine and scenario design. Peculiar properties of JT-60SA are its capability to produce long-pulse, high-?, and highly shaped plasmas. The preparation of the JT-60SA Research Plan, plasma scenarios, and exploitation are producing physics results that are not only relevant to future JT-60SA experiments, but often constitute original contributions to plasma physics and fusion research. Results of this kind are presented in this paper, in particular in the areas of fast ion physics, high-beta plasma properties and control, and non-linear edge localised mode stability studies.
Plasma shape control assessment for JT-60SA using the CREATE tools
G De Tommasi, H Fernandes, E Joffrin, M Mattei, A Mele, Y Miyata, A Pironti, T Suzuki, H Urano, F Villone
This paper deals with the plasma shape control problem in JT-60SA. An assessment of the plasma shape control performance is presented, aimed at the definition of an optimal set of gaps to be controlled. Indeed, JT-60SA represents a relevant benchmark to further validate this control approach given the high beta regimes that are envisaged during its operation. Moreover, such regimes represent a challenge from the plasma magnetic control perspective.
The control approach considered for the assessment is based on the eXtreme Shape Controller (XSC), since such an approach permits to control, in a least mean square sense, a number of shape descriptors that is larger than the number of poloidal field coils. Considering that the design of the XSC is model-based, the CREATE linear model for the plasma-circuit response has been used for the design.
In the presented analysis, the capability of tracking different plasma shapes, as well as the one of rejecting disturbances has been considered. The result of this analysis suggests that a set of about 20 gaps equally spaced along the plasma boundary permits to control the shape with a steady-state root-mean square error of less than 1 cm during the flattop of JT-60SA Scenario 2, in the presence of a set of relevant disturbances.
MIMO Shape Control at the EAST tokamak: simulations and experiments
A Mele, R Albanese, R Ambrosino, A Castaldo, G De Tommasi, ZP Luo, A Pironti, QP Yuan, W Yuehang, BJ XiaoDuring 2016-2018 experimental campaigns, the plasma magnetic control architecture of the EAST tokamak was revised in order to achieve improved performances, with the final aim of feedback control of alternative divertor configurations (i.e. with multiple X-points). This paper reports on the results obtained with the Multi-Input-Multi-Output (MIMO) plasma shape controller tested during the last experimental campaign, which prompted a considerable improvement of the control performances. Simulation results are also discussed.
2018
Model-based plasma vertical stabilization and position control at EAST
BJ Xiao, R Albanese, R Ambrosino, A Castaldo, ZP Luo, A Mele, A Pironti, QP YuanThis paper deals with the model-based approach that has been adopted to design the plasma magnetic control at the EAST tokamak. Such a design approach, which is based on a linear model for the response of the plasma and of the surrounding coils, has been successfully applied in 2016 to design an alternative solution for the plasma vertical stabilization, the plasma centroid position control, and the controller of the currents in the poloidal field circuits. After an introduction to the linear model for the plasma/circuits response, the proposed control algorithms are presented together with the preliminary results obtained during the 2016 experimental campaign at EAST. A brief description of the ongoing and future design activities is also given.
Status of the ITER remote experimentation centre
J Farthing, T Ozeki et al.
The ITER Remote Experimentation Centre (REC) project (one of the three sub-projects of the International Fusion Energy Research Centre (IFERC)) is progressing under the agreement between the Government of Japan and the European Atomic Energy Community for the joint implementation of the Broader Approach (BA) activities in the field of fusion energy research. The objectives of the REC activity are to identify the functions and solve the technical issues for the construction of the REC for ITER at Rokkasho, and to develop the remote experiment system and verify the functions required for remote experimentation by using the Satellite Tokamak (JT-60SA) facilities to facilitate the future exploitation of ITER and JT-60SA. The functions of REC will be tested, and the total system will be demonstrated using JT-60SA and existing facilities in the EU, such as JET and WEST.
The hardware of the REC has been prepared in Rokkasho Japan, which has the remote experiment room with a large video wall to show the plasma and operation status, IT equipment and a storage system by the reuse of the Helios supercomputer tape library. A broadband network infrastructure of 10Gbps has been installed connected to SINET5. Using this network system, fast data transfer from ITER to REC was examined in 2016, and the transfer of the data volumes expected for the initial ITER experiments has been demonstrated. A secure remote experimentation system has been developed, using JT-60SA, that has functions for preparing and setting of shot parameters, viewing the status of control data, streaming of the plasma status, data-exchange function of shot events, and monitoring of the facility operation. Remote data analysis techniques, data visualisation software, a documentation management and experiment planning system and numerical simulation codes for the preparation and performance estimation of discharges have also been developed.
2017
ITER-like vertical stabilization system for the east Tokamak
A Castaldo, G De Tommasi, ZP Luo, A Mele, A Pironti, BJ Xiao, QP Yuan
A ITER-like vertical stabilization (VS) algorithm has been successfully deployed and commissioned at EAST. The proposed algorithm decouples the VS from the plasma shape control, while the algorithms previously implemented to stabilize the EAST plasma exhibit a strong coupling with plasma shape control system. As a consequence, the VS algorithms previously implemented at EAST prevent the deployment of advanced multi-input-multi-output (MIMO) plasma shape control schemes, such as the ones proposed in Albanese et al 2016 (Proc. 2016 IEEE Multi-Conf. System Control (Buenos Aires, Argentina) pp 611-6) and Kolemen et al (2015 J. Nucl. Mater. 463 1186). Indeed, such MIMO controllers rely on the decoupling with the VS system.
The proposed ITER-like stabilizes the plasma column (i.e. it controls to zero the plasma vertical speed) on the fastest possible time scale, while leaves the control of the plasma vertical position to the plasma shape controller. Thanks to this frequency separation approach, the plasma shape controller can than be designed starting from the stabilized system, without explicitly taking the VS into account. In this paper we present the implementation details of the adopted solution for the EAST vertical stabilization, together with the results obtained during the 2016 experimental campaign.
Physics and operation oriented activities in preparation of the JT-60SA tokamak exploitation
G Giruzzi, M Yoshida, et al.The JT-60SA tokamak, being built under the Broader Approach agreement jointly by Europe and Japan, is due to start operation in 2020 and is expected to give substantial contributions to both ITER and DEMO scenario optimisation. A broad set of preparation activities for an efficient start of the experiments on JT-60SA is being carried out, involving elaboration of the Research Plan, advanced modelling in various domains, feasibility and conception studies of diagnostics and other sub-systems in connection with the priorities of the scientific programme, development and validation of operation tools. The logic and coherence of this approach, as well as the most significant results of the main activities undertaken are presented and summarised.
Control-oriented tools for the design and validation of the JT-60SA magnetic control system
N Cruz, G De Tommasi, M Mattei, A Mele, Y Miyata, A Pironti, T Suzuki
The construction and operation of the JT-60SA tokamak is the main project currently carried out jointly by Japan and the European Union under the Broader Approach agreement. Within the Integrated Project Team, Japanese and European scientists are developing and testing a number of tools to support preliminary studies and future operations of JT-60SA. Within this collaborative framework, European scientists are using a set of assessed modeling tools to design and validate possible solutions for the plasma magnetic control system of JT-60SA.
This paper introduces these tools and describes a possible control architecture to be used on the JT-60SA tokamak. The effectiveness of the proposed architecture is shown by means of numerical simulations.